QR Code
https://iclfi.org/pubs/wv/2026-uf-class-4

The following is comrade Jon Brule’s fourth presentation in a five-part Spartacist class series on the united front. Readings for this class can be found here.

This class is on the American version of the popular front. In the last class we talked about the Spanish Civil War, where the popular front took the form of a governmental coalition between the workers parties and a wing of the bourgeoisie. In the U.S. the left is too small to be invited into a coalition by the capitalist class. As James Burnham describes it, the People’s Front in the U.S. took shape as an alliance of the labor bureaucracy and reformists, including the Stalinists, with Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The alliance between the trade-union bureaucrats and the Democratic Party is intact today, although occasionally some labor official flirts with the Republican Party.

There are two points about FDR I want to make. One is myth and the other is stark reality. The myth, perpetuated by the trade-union bureaucracy, is that it was Roosevelt and his New Deal legislation that gave the unions the right to organize. In fact, it was three strikes led by reds in 1934—the Toledo Auto-Lite strike, the Minneapolis Teamsters and West Coast maritime strike—that opened the doors to organizing the industrial unions.

Only the next year was the Wagner Act passed. This set up procedures that provided a mechanism for organizing unions, but with the proviso that this whole process be overseen and regulated by the National Labor Relations Board and the government. The union leaders are totally enmeshed in these legal procedures, forsaking the class-struggle tools that forged the industrial unions, such as plant occupations and militant strikes that defied the bosses’ laws.

The second point, which is ignored by those who lionize the New Deal, is that it was based on a coalition of Northern liberals with staunchly segregationist Southern Democrats. So in the South (where the majority of black people lived) Jim Crow laws, lynchings and other racist atrocities were imposed by these Dixiecrats. This shines a particularly harsh light on the Communist Party’s political support given to Rooseveltian liberalism.

So how do you break the popular front? To begin with, stop supporting Democrats. One example of leftists who support the Democrats is the DSA, which is easily the largest socialist organization in the U.S. In the first class we had some discussion about the DSA, where there are three main tendencies. The first is the right wing whose program basically is to build the progressive wing of the Dems. Then there are the so-called “dirty breakers,” who claim to be for a split with the Democrats, but crucially not now. As a result, they end up capitulating to the right wing. Finally there are those who correctly fight to split now from the Democratic Party, such as the Just Break Already (JBA) caucus, which is part of the United Front for a Clean Break.

I want to make the point that to break the popular front it’s not sufficient simply to oppose the Democrats at election time, i.e., once every two or four years. That’s important but, as Burnham pointed out, “A reformist political line cannot be isolated into any supra-mundane sphere of ‘pure politics.’ It must show its effects on every arena of the class struggle.” While electoral tactics are important, they are not the only or even primary means to challenge popular fronts. What is really decisive is the class struggle itself.

One of the examples Burnham gives is work in the trade unions. He shows how the Communist Party’s support to Roosevelt led it to abandon class struggle methods more and more. Today the trade union bureaucracy subordinates class struggle to the Democratic Party, falsely claiming that electing Dems is the best way forward for the workers. And if you don’t challenge this bureaucracy, you aren’t really fighting for class independence, even if you don’t call for voting for Democrats.

One current example of how the bureaucracy works is provided by a recent strike of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union (ILWU) in the Bay Area. ILWU warehouse workers at C&H Crockett waged a strike against a cut in retiree medical benefits. On July 21, longshore workers from ports across Northern California walked off the job, poured into Crockett and built mass picket lines that shut down C&H’s scab operations. The action showed that the union had the power to win. But after one shift, the ILWU leadership ordered longshoremen back to work. In short order, the union tops took down the picket lines and proceeded to negotiate a sellout contract. During the strike, the union leaders ran straggly picket lines of little more than a handful of workers, while courting support from Democratic Party politicians. As the current issue of Workers Vanguard points out, the ILWU leaders didn’t want a confrontation with the bosses, who had charged the union with an “illegal” work stoppage. The union bureaucrats weren’t about to defy anti-union laws.

The ILWU is generally regarded as a left-wing union, although, as this example shows, the leaders’ refusal to go beyond anything sanctioned in law and its support to capitalist politicians makes it qualitatively similar to other unions. Of course, the unions would hardly have any existence today if they had always played by the bosses’ rules, as the ILWU demonstrated in its powerful 1934 strike. The lesson is the need to forge class-struggle oppositions in the unions. Hopefully some friends who have experience in the unions will make relevant points about this in the discussion.

Fighting Fascism

Now I want to delve a little bit into history. I will start with the November 1982 labor/black mobilization to stop the KKK from marching in Washington, D.C. First, the context. Washington was a majority black city with a black Democratic Party administration headed by Marion Barry, who at one time was a member of the civil rights organization SNCC. The black Dems tried their best to sabotage this mobilization, which was initiated by the Spartacist League. In this they were totally unsuccessful. Some 5000 mainly black and working people turned out to prevent the Klan from marching. Several dozen trade unions and labor officials endorsed this demonstration, including key sectors of workers from predominantly black waterfront unions in Tidewater, Virginia. At least 250,000 leaflets were distributed on the streets of Washington by volunteers for the labor/black mobilization.

As we wrote at the time, this was a “test of strength and will between anti-Klan demonstrators and the racist capitalist state” (“5,000 Chase KKK Out of Washington!”, WV No. 319, 10 December 1982). The D.C. cops had gone on a campaign to intimidate the protesters, denouncing “outside agitators” and telling Washington residents to stay home. But confronted with masses of angry anti-fascist militants on the spot, the cops backed down. They announced that the KKK march was called off because “resentment was so great among the hundreds of ultra-leftist protesters gathered with thousands of other demonstrators at the fringe of the proposed Klan march route that a physical confrontation seemed likely.”

The reformist left also worked to derail this militant action. Some appealed to the capitalist state, either calling on it to ban the Klan march or, like the Socialist Workers Party calling on the city to “enforce anti-racist laws.” Workers World Party, with their All-Peoples Congress organized a rally far away from where the Klan announced they would begin their march—in other words, a diversion. In the article we wrote following the march, we pointed out what was behind all this attempted sabotage, namely the desire of the reformists for an alliance with liberal Democrats. At play here were two counterposed strategies: mobilization of the workers and oppressed versus a popular front alliance with the Democrats in a futile effort to suppress the necessary anti-fascist struggle.

This was a real united front, conducted under the watchwords of “march separately, strike together.” As you can see from the display in Workers Vanguard, the basis for endorsing the demonstration was agreement on one key slogan, “Stop the Klan!” The endorsers were not supporters of SL politics. They were mainly trade union officials who by and large supported the Democrats. But by endorsing the rally they signaled to their members that it was okay with the union to participate in the mobilization. And we were quite open with our political differences. You will see that the SL distributed its own statement that called for sit-down strikes against mass layoffs; break with the Democrats and Republicans; take America’s industry away from its incompetent, corrupt owners—nationalize it under a workers government, etc.

International Labor Defense

One of the serious problems on the left today is sectarianism. With increasing state repression, this becomes particularly harmful. Many organizations refuse to defend people who are not their members or will refuse to defend individuals and groups with whom they have political differences. A breath of fresh air was the recent united-front rally for the Prairieland defendants, sentenced to 30-100 years for protesting outside a detention center. This rally, initiated by the Partisan Defense Committee, brought together a number of socialist groups and left and anti-ICE activists in a vital defense case.

The Partisan Defense Committee, which works in accordance with the political orientation of the SL, is a class-struggle non-sectarian legal and social defense organizations that champions cases and causes in the interest of the whole of the working people. It is modeled on International Labor Defense, set up in the 1920s by the Communist Party. The ILD organized defense of class-war prisoners and ensured that they would not be forgotten by the living labor movement. They also provided stipends to these prisoners. James P. Cannon, who led the ILD in its first years, and later was one of the founders of American Trotskyism, laid out the principles that animated the ILD:

“Our policy is the policy of the class struggle. It puts the center of gravity in the protest movement of the workers of America and the world. It puts all faith in the power of the masses and no faith whatever in the justice of the courts. While favoring all possible legal proceedings, it calls for agitation, publicity, demonstrations—organized protest on a national and international scale. It calls for unity and solidarity of all workers on this burning issue, regardless of conflicting views on other questions.”

—“Who Can Save Sacco and Vanzetti?” Labor Defender, January 1927, reprinted in Notebook of an Agitator, Pathfinder Press, 1973

As Cannon went on to say, “The other policy is the policy of ‘respectability,’ of the ‘soft pedal’ and of ridiculous illusions about ‘justice’ from the courts of the enemy. It relies mainly on legal proceedings. It seeks to blur the issue of the class struggle. It shrinks from the ‘vulgar and noisy’ demonstrations of the militant workers and throws the mud of slander on them.”

One example of where a union did not shrink from a militant demonstration in defense of one of their own took place on October 27. The utility workers union, with the power to shut off NYC’s lights, mobilized to demand that the cop who murdered one of its members, black worker Koran Irvine, face murder charges. They packed the courthouse and surrounded Foley Square, demanding justice for Irvine. As a result, the court felt compelled to up the charges from manslaughter to second degree murder. This gave a taste of the power of organized labor when it flexes its muscle. Workers and their supporters must continue to mobilize: Jail the killer cop!

Elections: No Left-wing Shift

I would like to deal some with the midterm elections. First, the big victory by the Democrats did not represent a shift to the left in this country. But in order to examine this issue properly, it is necessary to take a step back and look at the context. Trump’s election in 2024 delivered a death blow to liberalism as U.S. imperialism’s dominant ideology and shifted the entire national terrain to the right. This was expressed in growing MAGA sympathies in the working class. This was in good part fueled by the liberals, who falsely blamed white workers for the oppression of black people, trans people and immigrants. But the turn against liberalism is not just some ploy by the right wing. It reflected the declining position of U.S. imperialism and the consequent need of the capitalist ruling class to dump the liberal values that it had previously invoked to mask the predatory nature of this imperialism. The Democrats are fully on board with this, dropping their previous liberal moralizing about the plight of the oppressed and leaving black and trans people and immigrants to eat dust.

Voters punished Trump for his failure to keep his promises such as achieving affordability and ending “forever wars.” At bottom, the Democrats simply took over Trump’s 2024 platform and ran on a program of economic populism, while denouncing “wokeness.” No more than Trump will they be able to meet the needs of working people here, and they are just as committed to maintaining the alliance with Zionist Israel. The Democrats may not ooze unvarnished white supremacy like Trump, but they are for tough immigration enforcement, have funded ICE for years and sent their police against anti-ICE protesters.

Notably, this was not just the program of establishment and centrist Democrats but also the liberal progressive wing, including the DSA electeds. They augmented their ranks by electing six new members of Congress and two mayors of major cities. The DSA electeds are not even pretending to be radicals. NYC mayor Mamdani calls his brand of socialism “pothole politics,” a version of “sewer socialism,” to draw attention away from his support to a scab-herding governor (Hochul), NYPD repression, Zionist organizations and the privatization of public housing, among other betrayals. DSA-endorsed Nithya Raman, who will become L.A. mayor, is an open Zionist and collaborator with the city’s real estate barons. The inevitable disappointment among working people with these progressives will in the longer run only serve to benefit reactionary forces. Already an ultra-right split in MAGA, including Tucker Carlson and neo-Nazi Nick Fuentes, is gaining support.

There were several independent socialist electoral campaigns that we critically supported. This included Brittany Kubicek, a DSAer who ran against the Democrats in Rhode Island, who got almost a quarter of the votes for a state representative in Rhode Island. Other credible showings in campaigns against the Democrats were run by the PSL’s Greg Levy, gaining nearly 100,000 votes in the Ohio Senate race despite redbaiting by both Democrats and Republicans. Andre Easton, also of PSL, picked up some 10,000 votes in the Bronx, running for Congress. These campaigns, which opposed capitalism and both its main parties, offered workers and the oppressed a real choice in the elections.

Some socialist groups view the elections as proof that there has been a “left shift” in society. An example is the Revolutionary Communists of America (RCA). While correctly opposing votes to the Democrats, they claim there has been an “undeniable leftward shift” in the U.S. (“Trump and MAGA Crushed in U.S. Midterms,” communistusa.org, November 5). Actually, there is a lot of evidence to disprove this assertion. To start with, presumably a left shift would be reflected in an intensification of class and social struggle. But in the months leading up to the midterms, the labor bureaucrats tamped down on strikes altogether to avoid causing trouble for the politicians. The level of deportations has risen, blacks are no less being brutalized by the cops, and there has been little or no pushback.

There is another thing to look at in the elections. Numerous referenda in the states were passed mandating conservative positions on social issues, often where people voted heavily Democratic. For example, in Colorado where Republicans were virtually wiped out, there were four such measures. Two were attacks on trans rights. One required school and college athletes to play on teams consistent with their “biological reproductive system” and another prohibited gender transition surgery on minors. In the heavily Democratic state of Washington, a measure was passed that went so far as to require students wanting to participate in girls’ sports to verify their sex assigned at birth—through either genetic or hormone tests or an examination of their genitals. Measures passed elsewhere in ballot polls included tougher laws for drug possession and requiring voter identification at the polls. The New York Times (11 November) noted: “While economic frustrations and anger at President Trump propelled Democratic wins across the nation, many voters were moderates and Republicans who did not stampede left when asked to take sides on hot-button social issues.”

Enthusing over a “leftward shift” that doesn’t exist is totally disorienting. If things are moving leftward, then just keep doing what you have been doing. This can be an expression of complacency, justifying a policy of not intervening in struggle, like the RCA. Or it can mean continuing to pursue opportunist policies that only deepen the rightward shift.

We have tried to indicate some of the things necessary to counter the right wing shift. In the first place, for class independence: break with the Democrats! Fight within DSA for a split with the Dems and their electeds. Build united fronts for defense of the left against state repression, thereby also facilitating debates within the left over revolutionary strategy. The left as a whole is pretty much divorced from the trade unions. It is essential to intervene there. This requires patience and persistence. Amazing results will not be achieved overnight in this period. But revolutionaries must seek openings, however small, to unite workers across the myriad divisions perpetuated by the capitalists and enforced by union bureaucrats—whether they be race, ethnicity, gender, tiers or craft. Link the fight of the workers to the struggles of the oppressed. By establishing a track record now, communist militants can win authority that will enable them to build a revolutionary current when the objective situation changes.


Class #4 Readings